Exhibitionist Sister – Chapter 9

Chapter 9 – Back in the Bathroom

Ashley, Madison, and Brian find themselves having more fun in the bathroom together.

Let’s just say that the following morning was pretty great.

Ashley and I woke up around eight. We just laid in bed for a while.

This is a little unrelated but truth be told, I was surprised at how readily Ashley entered a sexual relationship with her sister. At first they were basically hands-off of course, but Ashley and Madison had since moved to playing with each other’s tits and sucking each other’s nipples. That was certainly extreme for blood-relatives. I’m also surprised that Ashley gave me the “green light” to fool around with both Madison and Alyssa without any significant reservations, but I imagine she wants to be able to play with them too. Fair’s fair.

After about fifteen minutes of laying in bed, Ashley’s phone buzzed.

“Is it Madison?” I asked.

Ashley nodded. “She asked if I was awake.”

A moment later her phone buzzed again. “Well, I’ll be right back,” Ashley said with a grin, standing up. “Madison is about to shower and wanted to talk to me.”

“Let me know what happens,” I said, watching her as she walked out.

⚻

Ashley walked across the all and knocked twice on the bathroom door. “Madison?” she called.

“Come in!”

Ashley opened the door, entered the bathroom, and closed the door behind her in one swift motion. Madison was sitting on the floor with her legs crossed wearing just a bra and panties.

Before we get any further, I don’t believe I’ve really described how their bathroom looks. It’s pretty big, which makes sense since the two of them (Ashley and Madison) share it. Essentially, the sink is against the left wall when you walk in. There are two individual wells, and there’s a big mirror above the sink. The bath/shower is directly opposite the sink, though there is a large amount of space between the two. The toilet is in a little indentation with its own door more towards the shower, but the door is usually just left open.

“What’s up?” Ashley asked.

“So I was going to take a shower to wake myself up a bit because I didn’t sleep well last night for whatever reason,” Madison began. “And I figured — well, did Brian tell you anything about our conversation last night?”

“Yeah,” Ashley said with a slight grin. “He told me about it while we had sex, actually.”

Madison blushed and then laughed. “Of course he did.”

“It was especially fitting, actually,” Ashley continued. “He ended up fucking me in the ass.”

Madison rolled her eyes and chuckled. “You can never resist telling me the details of when you and Brian have sex, can you?”

“It’s not like you don’t enjoy hearing them,” Ashley smirked.

“Fair enough,” Madison shrugged. “You got me there.”

Ashley continued. “And let me guess. You figured now would be a good time to try playing with your booty since you’re about to shower anyway?”

“Mhm,” Madison said with a grin. She was blushing a bit already, too.

“Why am I here then?” Ashley asked. She sat down on the ground across from her sister.

“Well,” Madison said hesitantly. “I was wondering if you could, y’know, help me. If you would be comfortable with that, of course!”

Ashley grinned. “I was hoping you’d say that.”

“You were?” Madison returned her smile. “So you’ll help then?”

“Of course,” Ashley giggled. “Do you have any lube in here?”

“Uhh,” Madison said. “No, I forgot about that actually.”

“Okay,” Ashley said, hopping up to her feet. “I’ll go grab some.” She slipped out the bathroom and came back into her room. I was still laying in bed, just surfing around on my phone.

“What’s up?” I asked.

“So she is gonna try to play with her ass,” Ashley grinned. “I’m grabbing some lube for her.”

“Sweet,” I said, smiling back. “The thought of Madison fingering her butt — I’m assuming that’s what she’s doing — is really hot.”

“Right?” Ashley said, retrieving a bottle of lube from one of her drawers. “I’ll be back pretty soon.” She slipped back out of her room and into the bathroom, where Madison was still waiting on the floor. Ashley sat back down across from Madison, placing the bottle of lube off to the side.

“Thank you,” Madison said, blushing a little. Part of her was still a little embarrassed about being intimate with her sister, and I can’t say I blame her for still feeling a little weird about it.

“No problem!” Ashley said.

“So,” Madison said, her voice trailing off a bit. “What — how do I do this?”

“Well,” Ashley said. “I would start by just touching yourself like normal. Once you’re really turned on and feeling as relaxed as you can be, you can start rubbing just, like, the outside.”

“Okay,” Madison said.

“Is it cool if I masturbate with you?” Ashley asked.

“Of course,” Madison smiled. “That would probably make it easier on me. I love watching you play with yourself.”

“The feeling is mutual,” Ashley winked. She stood up and stripped off her panties before taking off her t-shirt and tossing it behind her. Evidently she was not wearing a bra underneath her shirt. Ashley sat back down. Her pink nipples stood erect atop each of her tits, and her pussy was already wet.

Madison couldn’t help but stare at her sister’s body. “Jesus,” she whispered.

Ashley grinned. “Come on, it’s your turn to get naked!”

Madison laughed. She reached back and unhooked her bra, sliding it down off her shoulders. Her nipples were already hard as well.

“Both of us got blessed with great tits, huh?” Ashley chuckled.

“Apparently,” Madison blushed. “I guess I need to take these off too?” She tugged gently at her panties.

“If you’re gonna play with your booty, then yeah, I’d take those off.”

Madison turned more red, but she nodded. She leaned back and hooked her thumbs into her panties. She slid them down her legs, kicking them off her feet. She leaned forward again and slowly spread her legs. Ashley’s eyes feasted hungrily upon her sister’s pussy. It looked similar to her own; Madison had small lips, and her pussy was a pretty shade of pink.

“You’re so beautiful, sis,” Ashley whispered.

Madison smiled. “Thank you.”

Ashley leaned back, using one hand to brace herself. She brought her legs up so that her knees were bent with her heels touching the floor and her legs spread wide open. She was giving Madison an immensely erotic view. Ashley sat before Madison — her sister — with her nipples hard as rocks, legs spread wide open, and pussy already wet. With a bit less confidence and elegance, Madison copied her sister’s positioning. She leaned back against one hand (leaving the other hand free for an obvious purpose), bending her knees and spreading her legs open wide. Both girls could see a tiny amount of the others’ asshole peeking out from between the others’ cheeks. And obviously their pussies were on full display.

Ashley ran her free hand over her own body, fondling her tits briefly for Madison’s viewing pleasure before sliding her hand down between her legs. Ashley spread her fingers out, tracing them down either side of her pussy. Madison’s hand did the same, tracing down each side of her own pussy.

Slowly, Ashley began to trace her middle finger up and down her slit as her sister did the same. Each girls’ eyes watched greedily as they pleasured themselves. Madison slid just her middle finger inside of her, moaning as she entered herself. Ashley did the same, except she slid both her index and her middle finger inside her. Both girls began to fuck themselves gently, Madison quickly adding a second finger to her pussy. Once Ashley’s fingers were sufficiently coated with her juices, she moved up to her clit, rubbing it in a circular motion. Madison continued to finger herself, increasing her speed slightly. Both girls were moaning softly.

“I love watching you touch yourself,” Ashley cooed.

Madison smiled shyly. “You’re so hot,” she said softly.

Madison slid her fingers out of her pussy and began to rub her clit. She moved her fingers in a left-to-right motion, thrusting her hips gently as she pleasured herself.

“I think I’m ready to try,” Madison said after another moment. “How do I go about this exactly?”

Ashley paused for a moment. “Normally I masturbate in bed so I can sort of prop myself up comfortably and use two hands, but that’s not as easy here.”

“Right,” Madison said.

“You know,” Ashley said slowly. “If you wanted, I could…” she trailed off, unsure how to phrase her thought.

“What?”

Ashley thought for a moment. “Well, to put it bluntly, I could play with your ass for you so you could keep rubbing your clit.”

Madison turned bright red and didn’t speak. She didn’t look horrified by Ashley’s suggestion or anything — just surprised.

“It’s just that it makes the experience a lot better if you’re rubbing your clit,” Ashley explained. “At least for the first time. Once you’re comfortable with it, obviously you don’t need to be touching your clit. But it really helps when you’re learning.”

“Right,” Madison said. “I understand.”

“If you don’t want me to do that, then that’s fine,” Ashley shrugged. “Like I don’t care obviously. Whatever works for you.”

Madison thought for a moment. Perhaps she was considering how Alyssa would feel if Ashley played with her (Madison’s) asshole, but Madison didn’t vocalize her thoughts in this moment as far as I know.

“If you think it would be best,” Madison said slowly after a moment. “Then you can.”

“Are you sure?” Ashley asked. “I only want to do this if you are absolutely certain that you’re comfortable with it and everything.”

“Yeah,” Madison said. “I mean, you’re my sister. I trust you obviously. And you’ve already played with my tits and everything.” She shrugged. “Touching my booty isn’t too much worse than sucking on my nipples.”

Ashley laughed. “Well, when you put it that way, I guess.”

“So what now?”

“Well, if I’m gonna be the one touchin’ your ‘booty’,” Ashley said. “Then you may as well just lay all the way down.”

Madison nodded and laid down on her back. Ashley considered the fact that this would be significantly easier if they were just in Madison’s bedroom, but it did make sense to do this in a bathroom since it was Madison’s first time experimenting with anal. What really would’ve made sense is to do this in the shower, but there wasn’t enough space for that.

“Now just sorta bring your legs up a bit and spread them.”

Madison did as Ashley said. She bent her knees and spread her legs. Ashley scooted up so that she was sitting almost in between her sister’s open legs. The sight before her was almost enough to overwhelm her — Madison was completely exposed. Her tits were out and her legs were spread wide open, meaning Madison’s pussy and asshole were on full display. Ashley had butterflies in her stomach from seeing her sister in such an intimate, erotic position.

“Would it be weird if I said you have a nice butthole?” Ashley asked, giggling.

“No, that wouldn’t be weird,” Madison laughed.

“Okay,” Ashley said, still giggling. “In that case, you have a really nice butthole, Madison.”

Madison just rolled her eyes and laughed. “Thanks, Ashley.”

“Alright.” Ashley said a bit more seriously. “So you should just keep masturbating like you were before. You can finger your pussy too, if you want. Just try to keep your hand up away from your ass so I have room.”

“Okay,” Madison said. She happily resumed playing with her clit. She was fairly nervous, but she was incredibly horny too, and thus very happy to be able to continue masturbating.

Ashley placed both of her hands on the inside of her sister’s thighs, causing Madison to jump. Ashley quickly pulled her hands back.

“No, no,” Madison said. “You can put your hands there. I was just startled; I don’t know why.”

“You’re nervous. Just take a deep breath,” Ashley said softly. “Try to relax. Focus on how good your pussy and clit feel. Try to enjoy this.” She gave Madison a smile.

Madison smiled. “I like when you say sexual things to me.”

“Oh really?”

“Yeah,” Madison giggled. “It’s weird, but having my sister talk dirty to me is really hot.”

Ashley grinned. “Come on, baby girl. Touch yourself for me,” she gooed. “Play with that beautiful little pussy for your big sister.”

Madison moaned softly. She was rubbing her clit with one hand and pinching a nipple with the other. “Jesus Christ, Ashley,” she whimpered.

Ashley squirted a dollop of lube onto her finger. “I’m just gonna rub this on the outside of your asshole, okay?”

“Okay,” Madison said softly. She had definitely relaxed some, and she was very much into the feelings radiating from her clit.

Slowly, Ashley brought her fingers to her sister’s asshole. In a very gentle, very slow circular motion, she rubbed the lube onto the outside Madison’s asshole.

“Good girl,” Ashley cooed as Madison whimpered and continued masturbating.

“That feels good,” Madison moaned. “I can’t believe you’re touching my asshole. Oh my God.” She sighed loudly.

Ashley giggled softly. “Me neither, honestly.” She continued to rub the outside of Madison’s ass. With her free hand, Ashley slowly caressed Madison’s thigh, rubbing it gently. She watched Madison’s face — her jaw hung open with a distinct look of bliss on Madison’s face. Her eyes were closed. Ashley’s eye moved down Madison’s body, next stopping to watch Madison’s fingers working her nipple. Madison pinched and tugged on her nipple. She teased it, rubbed it, played with it.

Ashley’s eyes continued to move down her sister’s naked body, all the while she was caressing Madison’s thigh and massaging the outside of her asshole. Ashley now looked at Madison’s pussy. It was incredibly wet. Ashley would’ve loved to slide her fingers inside of Madison, or even to wiggle her tongue inside her sister’s pussy, but Ashley realized that there was a good chance she would have the opportunity to do both of those things in the near future. There was no need to rush things.

She watched Madison’s fingers work their magic on her clit. Madison’s hips were bucking ever so slightly as her fingertips moved in small circles. Madison’s toes were curling and uncurling, and her back was arched.

Ashley removed her fingers from the outside of Madison’s asshole and squirted some more lube onto them. She resumed rubbing Madison’s asshole.

“Let me know when you’re ready to try a finger,” Ashley said softly.

“I’m ready,” Madison said. “God Ashley, I’m so horny.”

“You and me both,” Ashley grinned. She grabbed the bottle of lube and squirted some more into her hand. She then rubbed it all over her index and middle finger, though she was going to start with just her index finger.

“You ready?” Ashley said, asking for one final confirmation.

“Yes,” Madison said. Her eyes were still closed.

Ashley brought the tip of her index finger against Madison’s asshole. “This should go in pretty easily,” Ashley said. “And it shouldn’t really hurt, either. It’s just a matter of getting used to the feeling of something going in rather than–”

“Yeah, I got it,” Madison said, laughing. “Go ahead.”

“Sorry,” Ashley laughed. She pressed her index finger, which was thoroughly coated in lubricant, into her sister’s ass. There was some resistance, but Ashley was able to get the tip of her finger through Madison’s ass without much difficulty. After all, it was just a finger.

Ashley pushed her index finger roughly half-way into Madison’s ass before stopping. “That’s half my finger. How’s that?”

“Fine,” Madison said. “It’s weird, but not bad. It doesn’t hurt.”

“You want the rest?”

“I do.”

Ashley pushed the read of her finger inside of Madison until her knuckles came to rest against Madison’s asscheeks.

“And that’s all of it.”

“Doesn’t hurt at all, like you said,” Madison said. She was very slowly rubbing her clit now. “I can’t believe you’re fingering my asshole, Ashley.” She chuckled.

“Me too,” Ashley smiled. “Should I just leave it in? Or do you want me to, like, fuck you with it?”

Madison was silent for a second. “Fuck me with it. Be gentle, though”

Ashley nodded. That was a good sign — not that it would’ve necessarily been bad if Madison just wanted Ashley to hold her finger in place.

Ashley began to slowly slide her finger out of Madison’s ass until only her first knuckle was inside Madison. Then, Ashley pushed her way back in no faster than she had come out. Madison picked up the pace on her clit again, getting back into her former rhythm. Ashley gradually increased the speed at which she finger-fucked Madison’s asshole until she was going at a moderate pace. It was not fast at all, not by any means, but it wasn’t slow either. And Madison definitely seemed to be enjoying it. She was moaning an awful lot.

“Does it feel good?” Ashley asked.

“Yes,” Madison groaned. “I think I want to try two fingers.”

“Great,” Ashley grinned. She slid her index finger out and positioned both her index and middle finger together at Madison’s ass. Then, Ashley squirted a bit more lube onto her fingers, though they were both still quite wet.

“You ready?”

“Yes,” Madison said. She opened her eyes for the first time in a while and looked up at Ashley, who held Madison’s eye contact as she slid her fingers into Madison’s ass.

“Oh my God,” Madison said softly.

“You good?”

“Yes,” Madison said. “I like how this feels a lot more.”

Ashley slowly slid her fingers in until her knuckles were against Madison’s asscheeks again.

“What now? Should I leave ‘em for a bit?”

“No,” Madison breathed. Her eyes were closed again. “Keep fucking me with them, please.”

Ashley repeated the same process as before. She slowly inched her fingers back until the first knuckle before sliding them back into her sister’s asshole. Madison rubbed her clit wildly now. As Ashley began to slide her fingers in and out of Madison’s behind, Madison’s moans became more frantic and more urgent.

As Ashley came up to her former max speed, Madison’s fingers were a blur on her clit. Madison’s toes were permanently curled, and her hips bucked and thrusted as Ashley finger-fucked her.

“Oh my God,” Madison groaned. “Holy FUCK!”

Ashley braced herself against Madison’s thigh and continued finger-fucking her little sister’s asshole.

“You like having your sister finger-fuck your ass, huh Madison?” Ashley cooed.

“Yes,” Madison groaned. “Oh my God Ashley, yes!”

“I want you to come nice and hard for me,” Ashley said. She was almost taking on the role I had when Ashley and I had sex, although Ashley was not nearly as dominating as I often am. “Come for me, baby girl. I want to feel your asshole throbbing around my fingers.”

“Uggghhhh,” Madison groaned. “Oh my God, Ashley. Don’t stop, you’re gonna make me come. Oh my God, I’m gonna come!”

“Come for me, Madison,” Ashley cooed. “Come for me, baby girl. Come for your big sister.”

Madison arched her back and cried out. Ashley felt Madison’s asshole begin to throb and pulse around her fingers. She was worried that her parents would hear Madison’s cries of ecstasy.

Madison bucked her hips and massaged her clit wildly. Her pussy was absolutely soaked. Her orgasm hit her like a truck, intensified by Ashley’s fingers sliding in and out of Madison’s ass. Her body bucked and spasmed as she rode out wave after wave of pleasure. The feeling of Ashley’s fingers sliding in and out of her asshole was like nothing Madison had ever experienced before. As she finally stopped coming, Madison sighed deeply. Ashley quickly slid out of her ass and washed her hands. Madison was breathing hard.

“So?” Ashley asked, smiling. “How was that?”

“Amazing,” Madison said as she tried to catch her breath. “I loved how it felt when you had two fingers inside me. One was alright, but two felt incredible.”

“I could tell,” Ashley grinned. “I’m surprised you enjoyed it so readily. It actually took me a while to get used to the feeling.”

Madison sat up and leaned against the tub. “Yeah, I don’t know,” she shrugged. “I definitely liked it, though.”

“I’m glad,” Ashley said. She leaned forward with her arms spread. Madison leaned forward and accepted Ashley’s hug.

“Thank you for helping me,” Madison said as they held each other.

“Of course,” Ashley said. She kissed Madison on the cheek before breaking their embrace. “Normally I would stay and make myself come, but I’m actually starving for some reason.” Ashley picked up her shirt and her panties and slid them on. “I’m gonna go eat breakfast.”

“Okay,” Madison said, yawning. “I guess I’m still gonna shower. Where’s Brian?”

“He’s in my room still, probably,” Ashley said. She had put on her panties and was now pulling her shirt over her head. “I imagine he’s urgently waiting for me so I can tell him what happened, although I’d honestly be surprised if he didn’t hear you coming.”

“Was I that loud?” Madison turned bright red. “Do you think anyone else heard?”

“Uh, yeah, you were loud,” Ashley laughed. “But I don’t think anyone else heard. Plus, mom and dad are probably not even awake yet.” That last part was a bit of a lie. There was a chance somebody heard, at least if they were by the stairs, but it’s true that their parents were likely still sleeping. It was only about 8:30am, and they usually didn’t get up until at least 9am.

“That’s good,” Madison said. “I guess I’ll see you after breakfast. I’ll have to get you back for making me come this morning.”

“Well, I only really helped you come,” Ashley grinned. “But yeah, for sure. Maybe you can finger my ass next time.” She gave Madison a wink and quickly crept out of the bathroom. She darted across the hall back to her room, where I was waiting. I had definitely heard Madison’s orgasm, and I was still pretty hard. (Hearing it made me hard. What do you expect?)

“Sounds like you guys had fun,” I said as Ashley came blasting through the door. “Why are you in such a hurry?”

“I’m hungry,” Ashley said. “And I’m pretty sure Madison would be happy if you went to the bathroom right now. She asked where you were as soon as we finished.”

“Really?”

“Mhm,” Ashley smirked. “Go on. She can fill you in on the details.” Ashley grabbed a pair of shorts from her dresser and slipped them out. We walked out of her room together. She continued down the hall while I stopped at the bathroom door. She blew me a kiss as she turned the corner to head towards the steps.

⚻

I knocked twice on the bathroom door.

“Uh,” I heard Madison’s voice. “I’m in here!” I guess she wasn’t sure if it was me so she was warning whoever may have been knocking that the bathroom was occupied.

“It’s Brian,” I said.

“Oh, okay,” she called. “You can come in!”

I quickly opened the door and closed it behind me, locking it. My heart skipped a beat when I saw Madison sitting naked on the ground in front of the bathtub. She was sitting with her legs crossed so I couldn’t really see between her legs too well, but I could see a strip of public hair peeking out above her calves. What I could see were her naked tits, and even though this wasn’t my first time seeing her them, you best believe I became rock-hard instantly. There was something so dirty about getting to see the naked tits of my girlfriend’s sister. Knowing my girlfriend had sucked on those nipples — her sister’s nipples — made it even better.

I was only wearing a pair of boxers (and nothing else) so it was immediately obvious that I got a boner. Madison blushed and smiled when she saw how hard I got (and how quickly I got hard for that matter).

“You’re already hard?” she said. It wasn’t so much a question as an observation.

“Oh yeah,” I grinned. “You’re naked. How could I not be hard?”

“Well, it’s very flattering,” she said, still smiling.

I went and sat down across from her, much like Ashley had done when she first walked in.

“Did Ashley tell you anything?” Madison asked.

“No,” I said. “But based on the fact that you’re naked and your nipples are still hard, I have a feeling you and Ashley had a little fun together.”

Madison blushed again and looked down at her chest, noticing that indeed her nipples were quite hard.

“I could just be cold, y’know,” she smirked.

“Well, are you cold?” I teased.

“No,” she laughed. Then she grinned at me. “I kept my promise from last night.”

“Did you now?” I returned her excited grin.

“Mhmmm. And obviously I recruited Ashley for help. She came in here and at first, we just masturbated together.”

“Right.” My dick was already leaking precum in my boxers. I don’t think I’ll ever stop getting ridiculously turned on by my girlfriend and her sister masturbating together.

“And then when I decided I was ready, we discovered that the positioning was a little awkward. Like I couldn’t easily prop myself up to comfortably rub my clit and touch my butt at the same time, which is what Ashley suggested I should do. It just wasn’t particularly comfortable.”

“Sure,” I said. I guess I understood what she was saying. I mean, I don’t think it would’ve been particularly difficult to get a finger in her ass while she masturbated, but I imagine she was nervous and whatnot.

“So Ashley offered to play with my butt herself so I could focus on rubbing my clit and being comfy.”

My jaw dropped. “And did she?”

Madison just smiled and nodded.

“Ho-ly shit,” I said. My girlfriend actually fingered her sister’s asshole! Or at least, I assumed she did. Madison hadn’t explicitly said that yet.

“Yeah, it was admittedly pretty awesome,” Madison said. She was all smiles right now. “At first, she just rubbed the outside of my butthole. Once I was ready though, she stuck her finger inside me.”

“Did you like how it felt?” I asked. My cock was throbbing at this point. I wish I had been there to see this. Ashley fingering Madison’s asshole? Holy fuck.

Madison nodded. “Yeah. It was a little weird at first for sure, but I got used to it pretty quickly. I actually had Ashley put a second finger inside me. Now that really felt good.”

“Two felt better than one, eh?” I asked, amused. “Seems like your ‘poor little butthole’ can handle more than you thought.”

Madison laughed. “I guess so. Ashley said it took her way longer to start enjoying the feeling than it took me.” She shrugged. “I thought it was great.”

“I have to ask, did the fact that your own sister was the one, you know, fingering your ass make it better or hotter or whatever?”

“Yes,” Madison said, blushing. “Fooling around with Ashley feels so dirty and so wrong. That makes it a lot hotter.”

“I mean, I agree,” I said, shrugging. “So is that all the details you have for me then?”

“Basically,” Madison said. “She did, like, actually finger-fuck me. She didn’t just leave her fingers inside me without moving them or anything.”

“Jesus,” I said. “I really wish I was there to see that.”

“Yeah, it must’ve been quite a sight to behold,” she giggled.

“Did you come?” I asked with a slight grin.

“Yeah, it felt great,” she said with a smile. “Aren’t you proud of me? I managed to have two fingers in my butt!”

I laughed. “Yes Madison, I’m proud of you.” She laughed with me.

She let out a sigh and then was silent.

“I guess I’ve gotten you pretty worked up, huh?” she asked after a moment. She was looking at the large bulge in my boxers.

“I’d say so, yeah,” I chuckled.

She blushed and then looked back down at my bulge. “Isn’t it a little unfair that I’m sittin’ here naked and you’ve still got underwear on?”

“Y’know, I do see your point,” I said, playing along. “You reckon I should take these off?”

“Well, it would only be fair,” she said.

I smirked. “I suppose you’re right.” I stood up and hooked my thumbs into my boxers, sliding them down off my legs, allowing my cock to spring free. I kicked them off my feet, and they settled in a clump behind where I was sitting. I stayed standing for a moment, letting Madison get a good look at my cock. She looked at it hungrily.

“Better?” I asked after a moment. I sat back down but didn’t cross my legs.

“Much better,” Madison nodded. “Although…”

“What is it?”

“It’s just that your, erm, ‘thing’ just looks so swollen and hard,” she said, biting her lip softly. “It really looks like it needs some attention.”

I looked down at my dick. “I think you’re right,” I said. “What do you think I should do?”

“Hmm,” she said, pretending to consider various options. “Honestly…” she paused for another moment. “I think you need to have an orgasm. What do you think?”

“That’s a good idea,” I nodded. “It’s just… I don’t know, I’m kind of groggy after just waking up, you know?”

Madison laughed. “Would you like some help, Brian?”

“Yes, please,” I nodded eagerly.

“You should come here,” she said, reaching behind her and patting the side of the bathtub. I nodded and stood up. I walked over — my cock bouncing up and down with each step — and sat on the edge of the bathtub with my feet outside the tub. Madison swiveled around on the ground to face me, sitting on her knees now. Madison grinned. I spread my legs a bit and braced my hands on either side of me against the edge of the bathtub. My cock was sticking out into the air with my balls hanging down beneath it.

“May I?” she gestured towards my dick with her hand.

“By all means,” I said, suppressing a grin. “It’s been a while since you’ve played with a cock, hasn’t it?”

Madison nodded. “Too long.”

She reached over and grabbed the lube. She blushed a little as she uncapped the top and squirted some lube onto my dick, which at this point was throbbing and genuinely in dire need of attention. Madison recapped the bottle and placed in on the edge of the bathtub next to me.

After taking a shaky breath, Madison slowly gripped the base of my cock with both hands. She began to slide her hands up my cock, her thumbs tracing over my balls before running up the underside of my shaft while the rest of her fingers wrapped around my cock itself. She gently massaged the lubricant all over my swollen cock, savoring the feeling of having a hard dick in her hands for the first time in a while. Once my dick was thoroughly coated, she traced the fingertips of her left out slowly down my shaft. From there, she took my balls into her hand and began to gently massage them. The entire time, my toes were curling and I was moaning loudly. She really knew how to work a cock.

“I love listening to you moan,” Madison whispered softly as she began to stroke my shaft with her right hand. Her left hand continued to play with my balls. She gripped my shaft more firmly and slid her hand up and down.

Normally I’m not a huge fan of handjobs, but getting a handjob from my girlfriend’s sister when my dick was covered in lube? Count me in. I mean, Madison was basically just worshipping my sex with her hands.

“I love watching you play with my cock,” I said in response, whimpering as she slowly began to increase her speed. My eyes followed her hand as it slid up and down my shaft. As she stroked me faster, her tits began to bounce in rhythm with her pumping my cock. Her nipples were hard, and I’m sure her pussy was nice and wet.

“Please don’t stop, Madison,” I groaned. She was stroking me quickly now; the sound of her hand pumping up and down my cock filled the room. From the look on her face, I could tell she was enjoying this at least as much as I was.

“I can’t wait to feel your cock throb in my hands as you come,” she said softly. She bit her lip and eyed my swollen cockhead, waiting eagerly for her reward.

That just about pushed me over the edge. “You’re gonna make me come, Madison,” I groaned. “Oh my God, please don’t stop! Fuck!”

“Come for me, baby,” Madison cooed as she stroked me. “I want this big cock to shoot all over me. Don’t you wanna cum all over your girlfriend’s little sister?”

“Yes!” I cried. “Oh fuck, I’m gonna come! Oh my God, fuck yes. Don’t stop, Madison!”

I braced myself against the edge of the tub as best I could. My toes curled hard as the first rope of cum erupted out of my cock, landing on Madison’s cheek.

“Oh my fucking God,” I grunted as I shot another two ropes onto her tits. The first landed on her right boob just above her nipple while the other was a bullseye, hitting her left nipple directly.

Madison’s hand flew up and down my cock, coaxing as much cum and as much pleasure from it as she could. Her left hand was playing my balls, massaging them and milking as much cum from them as possible. My orgasm ended with me crying out as another three ropes erupted out of my cockhead and landed on her face. As I finally stopped ejaculating, she let go of my cock.

“Holy shit,” she said. She stood up to look at herself in the mirror. I got a great view of her ass as she stood up and walked away from me. Her buttcheeks were big and round; honestly she really did have a booty that rivaled Ashley’s.

I was breathing hard. “Thank you,” I said.

“You’re welcome,” she looked at me, grinning. “I think I look hot covered in your cum. What do you think?”

“You look very hot,” I smiled.

She sighed happily. “Your cock was throbbing like crazy while you came,” she said. “It was so sexy. Like feeling it in my hands pulse and throb while you ejaculated on me — that was so fucking hot.”

“It tends to do that,” I laughed. “I’m glad you enjoyed it.” She must have really enjoyed stroking me off. She sounded like the happiest person on the planet right now.

“Dude, I’ll jerk you off whenever you want,” she said. “Like that was fucking great.”

“Oh really?” I smirked. “How about right now?”

“Could you actually go again already?” she asked, raising an eyebrow. “You came a lot. I’d be surprised if those balls of yours weren’t empty. But then again, Ashley loves to tell me how many times she’ll make you come in a night.” The fact that we were having this conversation while she stood naked, covered in my semen was certainly helping me be ready to go again.

“Maybe, I don’t know,” I said, laughing. “I was just curious if you really meant you’d jerk me off ‘whenever I wanted.’”

“Oh,” Madison said. She shrugged. “Well, if you are still horny then I’ll happily get you off again.”

I thought for a moment. “I mean, it’s hard not to be horny when you’re standing there in front of me naked, covered in my cum.”

She walked back over to where I was sitting and got back down on her knees. “So I should jerk you off again then?” She took my soft penis and balls into her hands. She gently massaged my balls and just sort of held my soft cock in her hand. It was slowly but surely getting harder.

I shrugged. “If you wanna make me come, then make me come. I am still horny.”

“I’d love to make you come,” she grinned.

KNOCK KNOCK

Madison turned white and shot up. I was a little startled, but the only other person that uses this bathroom is Ashley so I wasn’t particularly worried. I nudged Madison to respond.

“Hello?” Madison said. “I’m in here!”

“I know,” Ashley called through the door. She twisted the handle twice to point out that the door was locked and she couldn’t come in. “Unlock the door!”

Madison breathed what I figured was a sigh of relief. She walked over to the door and twisted the lock. Ashley heard the click and turned the handle, walking in and quickly shutting the door behind her. She made sure to relock it.

“Wow,” she said, looking at Madison. Her tits and face were still coated with the results of my last orgasm.

“What?” Madison said, mimicking the tone Ashley used that night when Ashley had flashed Madison in the shower. This was quite the role reversal.

“Nothing,” Ashley grinned. “You look hot covered in jizz like that, though. Just a bit more on your stomach and face and the look would be perfect.”

“Thanks,” Madison giggled.

“Though if it were me, I’d want some inside me too,” Ashley said.

Madison just laughed and rolled her eyes.

I was still sitting on the edge of the bathtub. My cock was back to being fully hard again. The fact that Ashley saw her naked sister covered in my come with easily enough for me to blast through the “refractory period.”

“You’re still hard?” Ashley smirked, looking at me.

“I think he just got another boner,” Madison giggled. “He was still pretty soft before you came in. Am I not good enough for you anymore, Brian?” she teased.

“Honestly, it’s just really hot that you’re naked in front of Ashley,” I said. “Especially since you’re covered in my cum.”

Ashley gave a nod of approval. Madison chuckled. “Fair enough,” she said.

“I didn’t mean to derail you guys,” Ashley said. She sat on the tub next to me. “What did I intrude upon?”

“Well, your boyfriend apparently has the sex drive of a thirteen year old boy,” Madison said. “I was going to jerk him off again since apparently he’s still horny somehow.”

I shrugged. “It’s hard not to be horny when there’s a hot girl willing to jerk you off as much as you want.”

Madison and Ashley both laughed. “Yeah, I guess you’re a pretty lucky guy,” Madison giggled.

“No shit,” Ashley smirked. Ashley came over and sat next to me on the edge of the bathtub.

Madison walked over to us and got back down on her knees. She reached up and held my balls in her hand, massaging them gently. Ashley leaned forward and whispered something in her ear. Madison looked shocked. I gave Ashley a curious look.

“Are you sure?” Madison asked.

Ashley shrugged. “I mean, yeah.”

Madison thought for a moment and then nodded. Ashley turned to me. “You should rinse the lube off your cock real quick.”

My heart skipped a beat. I had a hunch I knew where this was heading. I reached back and turned the water on. Ashley yelped and stood up, dodging the torrent of cold water from the showerhead. I scooted down a bit and held out my hand, waiting for the water to warm up. Once it did, I stood up and got in. We have a removable showerhead in that shower so I unhooked it and focused the water just on my dick. I rinsed the lube off of it and turned the water off.

“Do I need to dry off or…?”

“No, you’re good,” Ashley said. She grabbed a towel and wiped off the edge of the bathtub so she could sit back down without getting her pants wet.

Ashley took the hair tie she was wearing as a bracelet off her wrist and handed it to Madison, who quickly put her hair up in a ponytail. My heart was beating a million beats per minute at this point. I sat back down — a little further away so I didn’t drip on Ashley — and looked at her. She just smiled at me. I felt a hand grab my dick, which was not fully hard anymore, and another hand grab my balls. I looked back at Madison who had started playing with me again. She gave me a smile and scooted up closer to me. She looked so sexy with her gorgeous face and big, round tits covered in my cum.

She took her hands off of my cock and opened her mouth. Slowly, she inched her head forward. Time seemed to move in slow motion as she slowly took me into her mouth. As I said, I wasn’t fully hard yet, so she took the entirety of my cock into her mouth with minimal effort. She began to gently suck as I got bigger and harder in her mouth. Once I became too big for her to handle with ease, she moved down to my balls, running her tongue around them. I groaned loudly as she took my sack into her mouth and sucked it gently. I looked over at Ashley who just returned my look with a smile. She wasn’t even masturbating; she was just watching her sister suck my cock.

I looked back down at Madison. She made eye contact with me as she popped my balls out of her mouth. She ran her tongue from the base of my shaft to the head and began to twirl her tongue around the tip.

“Holy fuck, Madison,” I groaned, curling my toes hard as Madison worked my dick with her tongue.

Madison took the head into her mouth and began to suck it gently. She reached up with her left hand and held my balls while she began to pump my shaft with her right hand. She slurped and sucked eagerly on my cock, bobbing her lips up and down my shaft while her sister just casually watched. Madison came up off of my cock and took a breath before taking all of me into her mouth.

“Oh my fucking God,” I grunted as I bottomed out in her throat.

My balls were resting against her chin, and her eyes were watering slightly. She moved her tongue back and forth as best she could, teasing my shaft as she held me in her throat. She held me there for another few seconds, savoring the feeling of having a big, hard cock in her mouth. Finally, she came back off my cock, gasping for air. Strings of spit trailed between her mouth and my cockhead, which was absolutely soaked with her saliva.

She quickly caught her breath and took me back into her mouth. She was working my cock to make it come now. She was bobbing her head up and down, sucking the top half of my cock while she stroked the bottom half with her hand. At the top, she twirled her tongue around my cockhead, teasing the underside.

Ashley watched as her sister worked my cock like a pro. I’m sure her pussy was absolutely soaked, but for whatever reason she still wasn’t masturbating like she usually would. Madison continued sucking my cock. She started massaging my balls again with her free hand.

“You’re gonna make me come,” I groaned. Madison quickened her pace, sucking on me hard. The sound of her sucking my cock filled the room with let, loud smacks and slurps.

I arched my back and curled my toes as I felt the familiar pressure in my balls begin to rise.

“I’m gonna come,” I cried. “Oh my fucking God yes! Don’t stop sucking my cock, Madison!”

I began to unload inside of Madison’s mouth. She kept bobbing her head up and down on my dick as I shot rope after rope of cum down her throat. Ashley watched as I emptied myself in her sister’s mouth.

As my orgasm subsided, Madison came up off my cock. She opened her mouth and showed us what remained of my cum before swallowing it.

“Holy. Fuck.” she said.

Ashley laughed. “Did you enjoy yourself?”

“Yes,” Madison breathed. She was in the process of catching her breath. “Holy FUCK I forgot how much I loved sucking cock.”

I was still recovering from my orgasm, but I managed to chuckle. “You’re really goddamn good at it.”

Madison wiped her mouth off with her arm. “I know I said I’d jerk you off whenever you wanted earlier, but I’m changing that to sucking you off. That was so fucking hot.”

“I agree,” Ashley said. “It’s weird. If you were just about anybody else, I would claw your eyes out. But there’s something hot about sharing my boyfriend with my sister.” Ashley shrugged.

“I mean, I sort of understand,” Madison said. “I loved sucking his cock in front of you.” She looked at me and smiled. “I love watching you suck his cock, and I love sucking his cock in front of you.”

“Yeah, I love having an audience,” Ashley grinned. “Makes it better.”

Madison stood up and stretched. “Okay, I really need to shower. Don’t get me wrong, Brian. I love having your cum on me. But I do need to shower.”

“No, no,” I laughed. “You’re good. I can come on you anytime.”

Both girls laughed. “What a concept,” Madison giggled.

I stood up and moved over so Madison could hop in the shower. She got in and turned on the water, closing the curtain. I looked at Ashley, who had also just gotten up.

“Are we just gonna hang out in here?” I asked.

“Don’t leave,” Madison called. “If you stay, you’ll get to see me naked again!”

“In that case, we’re staying,” I said.

Ashley giggled and rolled her eyes. She took a step towards me and, to my surprise, reached down and took hold of her shirt. She pulled it up over her head and tossed it on the ground. She then hooked her thumbs into her pants and pulled those down, stepping out of them and kicking them atop her shirt.

“Oh God,” I whispered. “I just came, like, twice dude.”

Ashley cocked an eyebrow at me. She came over to me, grabbed my hand, and directed it towards her pussy. I felt.

“Jesus Christ,” I said softly. She was soaked. I know I just had two back to back orgasms, but come on. I guess that’s why she didn’t masturbate. She was just waiting until she could fuck me.

Ashley dropped to her knees and took me into her mouth. She sucked the mix of Madison’s spit and my cum off my cock and then continued to blow me. Once I was hard, she pulled my hand, directing me to lay down. I did as instructed, laying on the ground with my feet towards the shower. Ashley got on top of me and kissed my neck.

“Why are we always doing stuff in the bathroom?” I whispered with a slight laugh.

She laughed too. “I don’t know,” she whispered back. “It’s not like we only do stuff here.”

I chuckled. “I’m assuming we’re supposed to get caught here, right?” I was referring to Madison catching Ashley and I having sex.

“Duh,” Ashley whispered.

She reached back and grabbed my cock, pointing it up towards her pussy. She lined up my cockhead with her vagina and sat back down onto me. I slipped inside of her immediately. Good God was she fucking wet. Ashley braced herself on my chest and began to slide sort of diagonally back & forth and up & down on my cock. Even over the sound of the shower, I could hear the sound of my cock sliding in and out of her cunt. I wasn’t sure if Madison could hear, though. It turns out that didn’t matter though because Ashley made no effort to conceal her moans. She groaned and grunted loudly as she rode my cock. Sure enough, I saw Madison peak her head out from behind the shower curtain and gasp.

“Holy fuck,” I heard her say.

I shot Ashley a look that meant that we had been caught; I wasn’t sure if Ashley could hear. Ashley met my eyes and gave a slight nod. She arched her back and bounced her ass up and down on my cock.

I reached behind Ashley and grabbed her buttcheeks — one with each hand. As she bounced her butt up and down, I spread her buttcheeks wide open, giving Madison a completely unobstructed view of Ashley’s asshole (and her pussy). Madison could see Ashley’s buttcheeks as they bounced up and down. She had a great view of my cock going in and out of Ashley’s pussy, and she could definitely see my balls too. And now she had a perfect view of Ashley’s asshole being spread open as I fucked her cunt.

Ashley squeezed her pussy around my cock as she rode me. I could tell she was trying to make me come; Ashley wanted Madison to see me unload inside her pussy. The situation was hot enough that I had to make an effort to not come. I mean, my girlfriend’s sister was watching us fuck. Ashley must have felt similarly as I immediately felt her pussy begin to throb hard. She was coming! She usually didn’t come from penetration alone, but I guess the fact that Madison was watching us fuck (and could see everything) was enough to get her off with ease.

And that did it for me. The feeling of her pussy throbbing around my cock coaxed my third orgasm of the day right out of me. I began truly emptying my balls inside my girlfriend’s pussy while her sister watched. I curled my toes and gripped the bathmat we were laying on as Ashley’s pussy milked every last drop of cum from my balls.

As my orgasm finished, Ashley shifted herself forward so my cock slipped out of her. She wanted Madison to get a view of my cum dripping out of her cunt. And Madison sure did. My cock was lying across my stomach with a little bit of semen still dripping from the head. I reached back and spread Ashley’s asscheeks open again so Madison could clearly see her asshole. And beneath Ashley’s asshole, Madison could see Ashley’s pussy with a huge load of fresh cum slowly dripping onto my cock and balls.

Once Ashley was content, she rolled off of me and stood up. Madison just looked at her sister with a mix of shock and arousal.

“Holy fuck,” Madison said.

“I bet you didn’t expect to see that,” Ashley grinned.

“Definitely not. That was so fucking hot. Oh my God. You guys just fucked in front of me. Holy shit!”

I was still lying on the ground. “I hope neither of you expect me to be able to get a boner again anytime soon,” I said. Both of the girls laughed. “I think my balls are actually empty.”

Ashley came over and squatted next to me. She rubbed my balls, which had a little bit of the cum from her pussy on them. “Yeah, I reckon so.”

“You can’t actually tell, can you?” Madison asked.

“No, not actually,” Ashley giggled.

Ashley grabbed some tissues and cleaned both of us off before putting her clothes back on. She and I just sat on the floor until Madison finished showering. Sure enough, I did get to see Madison naked again. I got to see those gorgeous tits and her big, round ass. I could see the neat little landing strip above her pussy and the top of her lips too, but I never got a good look at her pussy or asshole. Not yet, at least.

---