PART FIVE: CONTROL

I got up the next morning and walked Renee to her car before heading to work. The problem that was developing was that each time Renee tried one of these new crazy things with me, she thought I would just be with her from then on and leave Amanda alone for good.

She had a difficult time understanding that she still had a boyfriend and as long as that was the case, I would never just be with her. If she left him, I honestly probably would’ve dated her exclusively. I liked her and she was ridiculously hot but, there was still that problem. By the time I got to work, the glow of her company had worn off and I began to think about the way she used having sex with her boyfriend to make me jealous. I started to get a little angry and felt spiteful.

I texted Amanda that morning and asked her out for drinks that night. It was Friday night again and I figured we could get a buzz and give Renee another reason to be jealous. It occurred to me that I was thinking too much about Renee. I was intentionally trying to make her jealous. I was playing HER game instead of my own. It wouldn’t do…

That afternoon, Renee texted me to ask if I wanted to see her again that night. I almost knew that if I told her that I was going out for drinks with Amanda, she would probably go fuck her boyfriend Henry again to spite me… I didn’t care. I wasn’t going to lie. I needed to take control again.

I told her the truth and didn’t hear back from her for the rest of the day.

That night Amanda and I went back to The Turk to have a few beers. Of course after we’d had a few, she asked me about Renee. I told her that I was still seeing her, but that we still hadn’t had sex. She moved on to tell me that she was going on a date the next night with a guy from her new job. She said that if I was going to be seeing two people, why couldn’t she. I don’t think she was interested in him really. I think she wanted to see if I would react. I didn’t besides to say that it was cool and I hoped she had a good time.

What happened during the next twelve hours was completely amazing!

Amanda and I finished up at The Turk around 1:30AM and headed back home. Jamie and Jessica were sitting out back drinking beers when we arrived, so we sat out there and hung out for a while.

After an hour or so, Jamie and Jessica went inside, presumably to have sex, leaving Amanda and I alone. Amanda immediately got up and walked over to me. She put her hands on my knees and leaned in to kiss me. After a while, she leaned away and said very conversationally “So are you gonna take me upstairs and fuck me or what?”

I felt that little devil on my shoulder and I grinned back at her. My game. My way. I stood and pulled her close. “Why go up stairs?”

She gasped as I shoved her backward onto the picnic table.

I quickly reached up her skirt and grabbed her panties. I yanked them off in one motion, and put them in my pocket. She was looking at me in awe. Sometimes girls like it when you completely take control like that. I walked up the side of the picnic table to stand next to where her head was resting. Very decisively, I unzipped my jeans and pulled out my cock. She stared at it and was breathing hard and fast.

I reached down and grabbed the front of her skirt and pulled it up so I could see her naked pussy in the moonlight. Anyone could’ve seen us from any number of the windows that overlooked that little courtyard. I think that was what she liked about it.

I slid my palm over her tuft of black pubic hair and felt that her cunt was already saturated. I loved how wet she got. She moaned as I slipped my middle finger inside her. I took a step forward and hung my cock against her cheek.

She rolled her head to the side and drew me into her eager mouth. Rather than being gentle, I began to finger-fuck her wet pussy as she pulled my cock into her throat. I liked the idea of someone watching us, even if no one was. I loved the danger of it all. I reached down to the left strap of her purple top and pulled it over her shoulder. She moaned her approval, so I did the same with her other strap and yanked the front of her top down hard to expose her pale breasts. I pinched her nipples and fingered her cunt as she sucked my cock in the cool night air.

I finally pulled away and walked down to stand between her legs. My cock was coated with her saliva and her pussy was dripping wet, so when I eased forward, I slid into her effortlessly. She moaned as quietly as she could and I gently began to push into her in deep slow strokes.

I pulled the straps of her top down further and she wriggled her arms through the holes so that I could pull her top down further to expose her tits completely. They rippled as I bucked into her and she quietly moaned into the night.

After a few minutes I began to get that feeling, but I didn’t want it to end yet, so I stopped. I slipped out of her and took a step back, pulling her up by the wrist to stand in front of me. She seemed to like fucking out in the open and I began to wonder how much of an exhibitionist she might be. I took another step back and looked her in the eye. Her gaze read only intense lust. “I want you to take off all your clothes.” I smiled.

“Out here?” she asked in a nervous voice. I could tell that she wanted to, but she didn’t want to seem indecent. I decided to push further.

“Yes.” I said. “Start with your top.” She nervously reached down to the bunch around her waist and pulled it up and then over her head. She then placed it on the table and looked up at me pretending to be shyly embarrassed. “You’ve got a great body.” I said. “Now I want you to turn around and take off your skirt.” I whispered. “I want you to push it all the way down to your ankles without bending your knees.”

Amanda slowly turned around and slipped her thumbs into the waistband of her skirt. She pushed it down slowly exposing her ass to me. As she continued to push it down, she bent further and further until I could see her little pink asshole. She then stood and looked over her shoulder at me. “Okay… Now what?” She was enjoying our little role playing as much as I was.

I thought quickly. I wanted to push her harder. “Now, I want you to climb onto the picnic table and get on all fours.” She was naked except for her navy knee socks and baby-doll shoes. She stepped onto the bench seat and put her knee down on the table top. She then scooted to the center of the table and dropped down to place her palms below her.

“Like this?” she asked over her shoulder. She looked incredible.

“Just like that.” I whispered as I stepped closer to her. I began to walk around the table, examining her firm toned body. Her eyes followed me. I decided to push it further. She was already physically exposed. I wanted to expose her emotionally. “Do you like getting fucked?” I asked very calmly.

“Yes.” She moaned.

“Good.” I smiled. I walked past her face. My cock was still hanging out of my pants. “Not including me, how many guys have you fucked?” I questioned.

She stuck out her ass a little. “Eight.”

“How many different cocks have you sucked?” I asked as I stopped in front of her.

She looked down and stared for a moment at my cock. “I don’t know.” She said with mock embarrassment.

“You like sucking cock don’t you?” I asked, stepping closer to her.

“I guess so.” She blushed.

I walked around her and stopped at her side. I placed my palm on the small of her back and slid it down over her ass. “Have you ever let anyone fuck you in the ass?” I asked as I slid my fingertip across her asshole.

“No.” she moaned. I let my fingertip linger there and I applied a little bit of pressure.

“Did you ever want to get fucked in the ass?”

“Not…” she hesitated. “Not really.” She was silent as I rubbed her asshole. Then she continued “I’m afraid it will hurt too much.”

I pulled my finger away and stuck it in my mouth. I then slid it over her rectum and applied a bit more pressure until my fingertip slipped into her asshole. “Does this hurt too much?” I asked.

“No.” She moaned.

I gently began to finger her asshole as I continued my questioning. “Have you ever fucked two guys at the same time?”

“No.” she paused to moan. “But, when I was in college I took a shower with two guys at the same time.”

“Did anything interesting happen?” I prodded.

“We kissed.” She moaned as I rubbed her asshole.

“Anything else?”

“I got on my knees and sucked both of their cocks.” She moaned.

She was having fun telling me things. Being honest the way I always was. I was turned on by that. “Did you make them both cum?”

“Yeah.” She moaned.

I slipped my finger deeper into her ass. “Where did they cum?”

“In my mouth.” She moaned louder.

“Have you ever kissed a girl?” I asked her.

“Uh-huh.”

“More than once?”

“Uh-huh.” She was moaning even louder.

“Have you ever fingered another girl?” I inquired.

“Yes.” She moaned.

“In college?”

“Yes.”

“Did she finger you too?”

“Yes.”

“Did you like it?” I asked.

“Uh-huh.” At that point I had pushed my entire middle finger up her ass and was working it around in circles.

“Did she eat your pussy?”

“She started to but I stopped her.” She moaned.

“Why?” I asked her.

“I was scared.”

“Did you eat her out?”

“A little bit.” She moaned.

“Did you like that?” I asked as I climbed up on to the table behind her.

“A little bit.” She moaned as I lined myself up behind her.

I eased my cock back into her pussy and continued to finger her asshole. “Do you like having my finger in your asshole while I fuck your tight little pussy?” She moaned an affirmative response.

I fucked her slowly and deeply as I worked my finger in and out of her butthole. She moaned and arched her back with each thrust. I finally felt her start to push harder against me and knew she wanted it hard. She wanted me to fuck her so she could cum. I was happy to oblige.

I fucked her harder and deeper and continued to finger her ass and soon she was moaning with little effort to keep quiet. I felt first her anus tighten around my finger and then her pussy flex around my cock. It felt amazing as I continued to pummel her and soon I was staving off my own moment of bliss.

All at once I pulled my finger out of her ass and my cock out of her pussy and started jerking it hard until I came on her freshly stretched asshole. She moaned as I coated her crack with my spunk.

We grabbed our clothes and went upstairs. We took a hot shower together and went to bed. She had me set my alarm for 9am telling me that she had to go to work in the morning.

The alarm went off at 9. I woke up first followed by Amanda. She got up and walked into the bathroom nude. Then I heard the distinct sound of Amanda brushing her teeth. Was she using my toothbrush? It didn’t matter. She finished up and returned to the bed with my toothbrush and a glass of water in her hand. “Brush your teeth.” She said handing them to me.

“What?” I asked. “I thought you had to work.”

“I do but not for two more hours.” She smiled as I took the toothbrush.

“So why did you want to get up at 9?”

She pulled the comforter off of me and threw it on the floor. She then plopped down beside me and started stroking my soft cock. “Because I wanted you to fuck me again before work.” She smiled. I stuck the toothbrush in my mouth as she bent forward and began to suck my cock which was getting harder by the second.

I finished brushing my teeth and rinsed with the water. I then spit it back into the glass and dropped the toothbrush into it and set it on the night stand. Amanda slid up my body and kissed me. She then wrapped her legs around me and guided my boner into her waiting pussy.

She rode me fast and wild for several minutes. Her body looked great in the daylight from the window and I loved watching her perky little titties bouncing up and down. Apparently she enjoyed getting her ass fingered the night before because she eventually turned around and rode me reverse cowgirl. She leaned forward to where her head was near my feet, reached back and started to rub her little butthole so that I could see. I took her cue and wet my thumb in my mouth. As soon as she felt it slide down her crack, she moved her finger.

I slipped my thumb up her butt and she howled with pleasure. I knew it would be a matter of time before she wanted my cock. She bucked and grinded me hard until we were both sweating pretty good.

She suddenly leaned back against my body and I wrapped my arms around her and held her tight. She tensed up and began screaming as I pumped her pussy. Then I pulled her upward and my cock popped out of her. I reached between her legs and started jacking my slippery cock until I shot my load up onto Amanda’s flat tummy.

Amanda looked over at the clock. It was almost 10. “Fuck!” she shouted. “I have to go to work!” She got up and hurried to the bathroom. “Call me tonight?”

“I will!” I shouted from bed. She returned to the bedroom and was clean of my cum.

She hurriedly slipped on her skirt and top. She then leaned over me and kissed me again. “God I love fucking you.” And with that she was down the stairs and out the door.

I lay in bed naked, still sweating. I stared up at the ceiling and thought about everything that had just happened. I drifted off into a little day dream.

I was really beginning to like Amanda a lot. She was very attractive and sweet. The sex was great and getting better each time and I was really getting sick of all the bullshit from Renee. The whole thing about her having a boyfriend was becoming more and more annoying. I was considering saying goodbye to her for good and really giving it a serious try with Amanda. Then I was suddenly interrupted by the sound of the front door opening and closing again followed by footsteps coming up the stairs. I didn’t get up or reach for the covers because I figured it was Amanda coming to say goodbye again. I just lay there proudly with my dick hanging out.

I was mildly startled when Renee stepped into my bedroom from the hallway.

“Do you always sleep naked?” she asked, smiling.

I put my hands behind my head. “Since I was fifteen.”

She climbed onto the bed and lay down beside me, placing her head on my shoulder. “It smells like sex in here. Did you have sex with Amanda again last night?” she asked.

“Yes.” I said as her hand began to glide down my chest toward my cock. I was beginning to think that it actually turned her on a little.

“Did you take a shower after?” she asked as her fingertips grazed over my cock.

I thought about it for a moment. “Yes.” (Technically, I wasn’t lying if you think about it.)

She started to coax my cock back to life with gentle strokes as she very conversationally said. “That’s cool. I fucked Henry again last night… Don’t worry. I took a shower too. I had to. He shot his cum all over my tits.” She was still trying to make me jealous. Now I didn’t have any reason to feel bad about what happened next.

She had managed to get me hard again. She leaned into my ear and whispered “Do you want me to take off my clothes now?”

“Yes.” I moaned as she gently stroked me off.

She rose to her knees and pulled off her tee shirt. Then she lay back down next to me and slipped her shorts and panties off. Last, she took off her bra to reveal those flawless tits.

Kryptonite!

She rolled onto her side and kissed me as she went back to stroking my cock. “So what do you want to do with me today?” she whispered.

I was a little pissed about her saying that shit about her boyfriend. In retrospect, what I did next was a little fucked up though… Forgive me.

“I want you to suck my cock while you finger yourself.” I grinned.

“Okay.” She said as she rose up again. She rose to her knees at my side and then bent down. She slid her hand between her legs so that I could see what she was doing. She then gripped my cock and slid her mouth over the head. I watched her bob up and down three or four times before her brow furrowed and she pulled away from me. “Are you sure you took a shower last night?”

“Yes. I definitely took a shower after I fucked Amanda last night.” I smiled. She just looked up at me with her eyes wide. “But not after I fucked her this morning.”

Renee jerked away and wiped her mouth on the back of her hand. “Are you fucking kidding me!?! You just let me put your dick in my mouth after you fucked that girl? When did you fuck her?”

“Maybe twenty minutes ago?” I smiled. I couldn’t help myself. I was angry at her. I wasn’t doing anything to be malicious, but she was using her relationship with her boyfriend to make me jealous. I felt I was justified.

“You are a fucking asshole!” she yelled as she stepped off of the bed. She grabbed her panties and began to put them back on.

“Okay, maybe that was a little fucked up, but did you really feel like it was important that you tell me about Henry cumming on your tits?” I protested.

“Henry is my boyfriend! It’s not like I tricked you into licking is cum off my tits!” she shouted. She had a point… I didn’t care. I was sick of all of her shit.

“That’s right. Your boyfriend, which I am not! I can fuck whoever I want Renee. I’m not yours! You belong to someone else, yet you keep coming over here and fucking around with me! You know I’m also seeing Amanda and you know I’ve been sleeping with her AND you knew I was going out with her last night! What the fuck did you expect?” I was ranting. “In this whole fucked up scenario, the only person that is cheating or lying to someone is you!”

The room was still and quiet for a full minute. I was sitting on the bed naked. She was standing at the foot of it in her panties and skirt. It was like time had frozen. In that rare moment, she hated me.

She knew that everything I said was true. I was right and she couldn’t deny it. It wasn’t until just then that I knew how into me Renee really was. All of the things I said would’ve driven almost anyone away. There were only two explanations as to why she didn’t finish getting dressed and walk out the door immediately. Either she was addicted to me or she was addicted to the danger of this little game we were all playing. Either way, she just stood there in silence.

Finally, she lowered her eyes to the floor and quietly said “If you want me to stay, you have to take a shower.”

I suddenly realized I had complete control. I seized it immediately. “What did you just say?”

“I said if you want me to stay, you have to take a shower.”

“Why?” I asked.

“Because…”

“Because you want to suck my cock again?” I asked

“Yes.” She said quietly.

“Ask me nicely.” I said defiantly. She was bending to my every word.

She was silent for a moment. Finally she spoke. “Will you please take a shower?”

“What for?” I pushed.

She took a deep breath and looked up to meet my eyes. It was like watching a prison movie. “Will you please go and wash your cock so I can suck it without tasting that slut’s pussy again?”

“That wasn’t very nice.” I said lowering my brow. “Try again.” I was loving this and I think she kind of was too. She was a kinky girl and she knew that I knew that.

She shifted her weight and glared at me. “Fine. John, will you please go and take a shower? I want your big fat cock to be nice and clean so I can suck it for you.”

“Why do you want to suck my cock?” I asked her.

She sighed again. “Because I love sucking your cock and making you cum.”

“Where do you want me to cum?” I asked. I couldn’t stop myself.

“Wherever you want.” She whispered.

I stepped off of the bed and grabbed her around the waist, pulling her close to me. I shoved my face into hers and kissed her. Her wild tongue shot into my mouth and we kissed wet and deep. Then I broke away and went into the bathroom.

I stepped out of the shower and wrapped the towel around my waist. When I got back into the bedroom I found Renee in bed under the covers. I saw her skirt and panties in a pile on the floor.

I grabbed the comforter and threw it aside. She lay on her side completely naked. Her body, flawless. She went right back into the role. “Can I please suck your cock now?” she whimpered.

I pulled off my towel and dropped it on the floor. My dick was already getting hard from looking at her beautiful body. She slid closer to the edge of the bed and turned her head and took my cock into her warm mouth. “That’s nice.” I said as I reached down and pushed her thighs apart. She spread her legs eagerly without any resistance. I watched her suck my cock in long strokes as I slid my finger over her clit and gently began fingering her. She began to moan aloud. “Did you really fuck Henry last night?” I asked.

“Mmm-hmm.” She moaned.

“Were you pretending he was me again?” I asked.

“Mmm-hmm.”

“What do you think he would do if he could see what you are doing right now?” I asked. I was trying to prove a point.

“Break up with me.” She said between strokes.

I applied more pressure as I fingered her. I had never fingered her before, but she wasn’t resisting me. In fact, she was getting extremely wet. “Would he call you a slut?” I asked.

“Uh-huh.” She moaned.

I remembered how much Amanda seemed to get off when I fingered her asshole. “Do you ever let him fuck you in the ass?” I asked as I fingered her.

She pulled her mouth off my cock and began stroking it. “I used to, but not for a really long time.” She moaned. “I want you to fuck me in the ass though.” She moaned before going back to sucking me.

“Yeah?” I asked. “You want me to put my dick in your ass?” I asked as I slid my middle finger further down and rested my thumb on her clit. I gently started rubbing her asshole with my middle finger. She moaned aloud. Then I remembered how much fun it was to interrogate Amanda the night before. “Have you ever fucked two guys at once?” I asked. She looked at me blankly for a moment. “You don’t have to lie to me.” I assured her as I began to push my finger into her ass.

“No.” she moaned and was quiet for a moment. Then she continued“One night I fucked one guy while I sucked another guys cock.”

“Henry?” I asked. I was doing the math in my head. It wasn’t adding up.

“No.”

“How old were you?” I asked as I slid my finger deep into her asshole.

“Ah! Fourteen. I was fourteen.” She moaned.

“Oh my god. You’re a little fucking whore aren’t you?” I giggled.

She just moaned. “Yes! I’m a fucking whore.” She curled her stomach to lift and spread her ass cheeks apart allowing me easier access to her sphincter. “I love sucking cock and I’m a dirty fucking whore.” she moaned. I slid my finger further into her asshole and she moaned louder “OH, FUCK! Can you do that with your tongue?” she begged.

I lay flat on my back and helped her sit up. “Put that fucking cock in your mouth.” I said as I pushed her forward. I then pulled her left leg over my head so that she was straddling my face. She pulled my cock into her wet mouth again and I placed my hands on her ass cheeks and gently pulled them apart. My chin was inches from her tight little pink asshole. This was by far the furthest we had gone and I was loving pushing all of these boundaries. I leaned forward and slid my tongue over her asshole and she moaned with delight. I decided to just go for it. I pushed my face into her ass crack and jammed my tongue out and forced it into her tight little asshole. She moaned like the slut she was and started sucking me even faster.

I ate her asshole and she sucked my cock for a few minutes. She kept moaning louder and louder. She had reached down between her legs and was vigorously fingering her cunt as I tongued her ass. It occurred to me that I had never gone down on her. I arched my neck down and pushed her fingers out of the way. I wet my thumb with spit and jammed it up her ass and she screamed in a mix of pleasure and pain. Then I immediately buried my tongue in her soft pussy. She moaned as loud as she could with her mouth full of cock.

I worked my magic for several minutes and am fairly certain I gave her at least two orgasms. Then without warning, she rose up and turned around. She straddled me across my stomach, facing me and she had this torn confused look in her eyes. She had grabbed my cock and absently started rubbing it across her clit. Her body was glistening with sweat and her hair was damp and hung in matted clumps across her face. Then she started making an indecipherable sound. She just moaned “Uh… Uh…” It was a mixture of anxiety and lust.

Finally she scooted back further and said “Oh fuck.” as she lowered herself down and my cock slid into her beautiful wet pussy.

I couldn’t believe it! A day that I thought would never come and here it was, happening right before my eyes! I was fucking the girl that would never let me fuck her!

Her pussy was surprisingly tight and felt wonderful. I could only imagine she had either lied about having sex with her boyfriend the night before, or he had a really small dick. Either way, I was happy.

“Oh, God!” she moaned as she slid up and down my cock. I placed my hands on her hips and she threw her head back. Her back was arched and I was quickly hypnotized by the rhythmic bouncing of her unbelievably perfect breasts.

She placed her palm on my chest and looked down to meet my gaze. Her face was a very distinct expression of extreme focus. I had never seen her look like that before. It was so hot!

She rode me for a few minutes and would occasionally lean down to kiss me. Finally she climbed off of me and got on all fours next to me. “Fuck me from behind!” she demanded. She had a beautiful ass and I was happy to do as I was told.

I positioned myself behind her and easily slipped back inside her. She pushed back into me hard, so I grabbed her hips and thrust deep into her. “Fuck me hard!” she yelled. “Fuck me as hard as you can!”

I was pummeling her from behind and her face was mashed into the pillows. She was moaning incredibly loud. I was immediately torn again. Now I was fucking both of them… Renee was hotter, but Amanda was single. I would have to think about all of that later, for as I was internalizing the situation, Renee shouted “Put your finger in my ass!”

I wet my finger and started to rub her butthole again. “Just stick it in!” she cried. “Finger fuck my tight little asshole!” She shouted.

I forced my finger up her ass and she cried “OH,FUCKING GOD!” and I felt her body tremble and her pussy gushed all over my cock. Seconds after I began to twitch and spasm. She immediately slipped forward and rolled over onto her back. She reached up with both her hands. In her right, she grabbed my cock and started jerking it over her face. With her left, she grabbed my wrist and pulled my hand to her mouth. She then took the finger I had just slid out of her asshole and took it into her mouth. It was too much for me to handle.

She jerked my cock inches above her face as she sucked her own ass juices off of my finger. I felt my hips lock and I sprayed a huge stream of cum across her face down her neck and onto her tits. “Cum!” she moaned. She pushed my hand away and opened her mouth wide. I spewed another stream onto her tongue. Her mouth closed briefly and when she re-opened it, it was empty. I quickly filled it again as she jerked all the jizz I had left out of my glistening cock.

I fell back against the wall, covered in sweat. Renee lay on her back looking up at me with my cum all over her face. I couldn’t take it. It was too much. Finally, she sat up. She grabbed my shorts and wiped her face. Then turned away and leaned back against my chest. I put my arm around her and we sat silently for what seemed like forever.

“I’m thinking about breaking up with Henry.” She said very softly. I was actually happy to hear her say that.

“Really?” I whispered.

“Would you want that?” she asked.

I thought for a moment, trying very carefully to choose the right words. “It doesn’t matter what I want. What do you want?”

“You.” She smiled. It was a bittersweet smile. She turned to look at me and there were tears in her eyes. “I don’t know… You probably think I’m some crazy bitch that cheats on her boyfriend.”

“No.” I whispered. “I wanted you the day I met you. I pursued you, remember?”

We didn’t speak of it again. We just lay there holding each other for several hours. When she finally did leave, I was incredibly torn.

I really liked Amanda. Up until that day, I hadn’t really had a strong emotional attachment to Renee. Everything was different now. Now I really wanted to be with them both.

Maybe I should choose Renee… She was insanely beautiful, and the sex was amazing. She was really into me…

Maybe I should choose Amanda… She was single and there would be less drama. She was also very attractive and playful. Sex with her was great too…

Maybe I should choose neither… I started this whole thing to get over Marie. I had only been single for 6 months when I met Renee… Maybe I owed it to myself to stay the course and enjoy being single for a while longer…

I don’t know what to do.
I don’t know what to do…

…….

Maybe they should meet…

NEXT: PART SIX: THREE’S COMPANY

---