The Secret Cheerleader Vote – #1

_____________________________________________________________________________________

This is going to be a series exploring the events resulting from Carly’s bet with Zane. It is based on a true story and a lot of what you will read actually did happen. However, some of it involves delving into the minds of other characters, so, we’ll call it fiction. I’ll let you decided for yourself where the truth lies.

After getting Carly’s younger sister in bed with him, Carly was now obliged to set him up with the entire school cheerleading team. How is that possible you ask? Read on! And enjoy.

As a note: The way I wanted to tell these stories requires sometimes getting inside the heads of some of the different characters. This requires a departure from my usual writing style. While I will still leave the comments open, please try to be constructive. I’m trying something new, and I’m still learning.

_____________________________________________________________________________________

The Set Up

Carly lost a bet, and now it was time to pay up. After catching her little sister peeping as she and her friend Zane were having sex, Zane bet her that he would be able to get the younger sister in his bed. Even though little sister was a freshman now, Carly still thought of her as the same little pest that she had grown up with. She was wrong. Zane barely even had to try. Her sister jumped into bed with him the first chance she got, and a few more times since then.

Carly had been so sure that her sweet innocent little sister would be scared away or even grossed out at the mere thought of sex, that she offered up the craziest thing she could think of as stakes, the entire school cheerleader squad. Carly was one of the senior co-captains and told Zane that if he won, she could arrange it so that he would have his pick of any girl on the squad, or all of them if he wished! He didn’t believe her of course, who could deliver on something like that? Then again, who could pass up an offer like that? So Zane accepted her stakes and the bet was on.

Carly’s Plan

What Zane didn’t know was that Carly had actually been working on a plan for this long before they made their bet. The bet just presented the perfect opportunity for her to put it into motion, and he was going to be the lucky beneficiary. IF he succeeded.

Her plan was actually very simple. At the end of every year, the seniors would all cast votes to determine who would be the co-captains, there were always two, for the following year. This was the team tradition. In addition to the seniors, the cheer coach and the faculty advisor also voted. This year there were only four seniors, so with the two additional votes of coach and faculty, there was the very real possibility of a tie.

Carly’s devious plan was to introduce the rumor of a tie-breaker vote. A secret voter. Someone not on, or connected to the squad, who would make the final vote and break a tie if necessary. Once everyone started believing in it, she would start the rumors that Zane was that secret vote. All of the juniors who wanted to be captain would be throwing themselves at him to be sure they secured his favor, and ALL the juniors wanted to be captain. Some of the sophomores too.

After Carly explained the whole thing to him, Zane began to think this could actually work. When he learned that the rest of the seniors all agreed to go along with it, it sounded even better. Why would all of them go along with such a plan? To help Carly pay off a bet? Probably not. To help Zane get laid? Definitely not.

Their real motivation? Revenge. Payback. Karma.

Why?

The reason Carly had begun dreaming up this whole plan in the first place was, Bella. Bella was one of the junior cheerleaders, and a top contender for captain. She was the girl that everyone loved, until she left the room. Bella was a devious little monster, always manipulating anything or anyone to make herself look good, no matter what it meant for anyone else. In the past three years, at some point, she had claimed her glory at the expense of each of the seniors.

Carly wanted to see Bella used and humiliated just like she had done to so many others, and she knew Zane was just the guy to help her do it. When Carly offered up a plan to get some payback, the other seniors all signed on. Carly’s only condition upon setting Zane up for this cheerleader free for all, was that he torture Bella. She wanted him to “Fuck that bitch up and make her beg you to do it.” and, get pictures. Carly wanted to make her humiliation complete. Zane was happy to oblige.

Hints

Within the next week, all the talk among the cheerleaders was about the end of the year vote. Carly made a big deal about the possibility of a tie, things were just that close. There were usually more seniors, this could be the first time in years that they need to use the secret vote. Gossip among the underclassmen instantly became, “what the hell is the secret vote”? None of them had ever heard of it before.

The seniors all started to fill in the story in the days that followed. They would talk over lunch and add a few details here and there. It would have to be someone not on the squad. It would have to be someone who knows everyone vying for captain. It would have to be someone they all trust. Does that mean it would have to be a girl? Hmmm, maybe, maybe not. It could be anyone.

Then Carly added her name drop. She recruited her sister Haley, the one she made the bet over, to mention Zane whenever she could. Haley was not a cheerleader herself but she knew them all, since they were always at her house hanging out with her sister. She would mention that Zane called when any of them were over, or tell them that Carly was at Zane’s house if they showed up and she wasn’t there.

Just to be absolutely sure that they all got the clue, Carly had Haley just say outright that she knew Zane was the secret vote, just once, to one person. She didn’t tell Haley that the secret vote was a scam, best that she think it was real as well. One of Haley’s best friends, Chloe, was a freshman cheerleader. Chloe was only on the JV squad, but she knew the rumors as well as anyone else. Carly asked Haley to just tell her it had to be Zane. Soon there was only one name circulating amongst the squad.

Chloe

The first hint that the plan was actually working turned out to be Chloe herself. Although Chloe had no chance of becoming captain, although she was a sure thing for captain of the JV squad. Still, there was a vote for JV captain too, and no one ever said the secret vote didn’t apply to that as well.

One Saturday afternoon some of the cheerleaders were hanging out at the school after practice. Zane of course happened to be there as well. He now tried to be anywhere the cheerleaders were at any given time, just to keep the rumors hot. When Chloe saw him there, she came over flirting and giggling at everything he said right up to the point where she cuddled right up on his lap and wrapped an arm around his neck.

This was an unexpected development. Who would have thought the freshmen were buying into this! Then again, Chloe was the only one who thought she knew for sure who the secret vote was. Amazed looks passed between Zane, Julie, and Carly. The juniors and sophomores were paying close attention too.

Chloe was slim, long sexy legs, long dark hair, big bright brown eyes, an amazing smile with the cutest dimples, great perky tits, and a tight little ass. Put all that in a cheerleader outfit and all eyes were on Chloe.

She was also a lot of fun. Chloe had an older sister who had been on the squad before her, so she had seen all the hijinks that go on and new it was all just for fun, so she was always ready to join in. Did she know this whole thing was a scam? Did she suspect? Was she just playing along? Or was she genuinely flirting hoping to gain some favor for when the voting came? Just what had Haley told her?

They all started making remarks and teasing Chloe about hitting on the upperclassman. She just giggled and laughed right along with them, remarking that she’s a cheerleader, you didn’t expect her to be dating FRESHMEN did you?

Zane, in the meantime, was enjoying his newfound friend, his hands doing a lot of exploring and touching, and seeing just how far he could go. He didn’t care if everyone there watched, he wanted them all to get some ideas as well. His hand slipped immediately to her smooth legs across his lap and started to rub right up between them. Chloe shifted her legs so the right one was a little higher, and not everyone could see his hand sliding up the inside of her silky smooth thighs. All eyes were on the two of them. His hand kept slipping farther and farther up that firm sexy leg, until it started to venture under her skirt. And Chloe? She just smiled and spread her legs just the tiniest bit farther apart.

They were all hooting and hollering. Zane’s hand was just about to reach her hotspot when Carly decided to dial it up a notch. She said “C’mon Chloe, how about a big juicy kiss!”

Chloe just smiled, wrapped her other hand around Zane’s neck and planted her lips on him. As she did, she crossed her legs over and trapped Zane’s hand between them, forcing his hand all the way up to her panties. Zane kissed right back. For a few minutes they opened their mouths and battled tongues while everyone cheered. His fingers did some teasing and exploring too.

Chloe felt tingles all throughout her body when his fingers touched her pussy. Even through her panties. This was everything she’d hoped. She thought to herself, she should have taken the panties off before she came over, wouldn’t he be surprised by that! God his fingers were so magical. Luckily, the way her legs were crossed it didn’t seem that any of the others could see what was going on down there, although at this point she didn’t care if they did. When they finally came up for air, everyone cheered.

Zane laughed along with the rest of them and then said to Chloe “Wow! That was great! But I think Carly meant SHE wanted a kiss!”

Again everyone laughed and screeched. Then Chloe bounced right up and over to Carly, sat down on her lap and did the exact same thing! (minus the fingers)

The hysterics could be heard for miles!

Take your pick

After that day Zane was almost always surrounded by cheerleaders. There would always be one sitting on either side of him, or one sitting on his lap, or hanging on his shoulder as they walked down the halls. They laughed at everything he said. They smiled at any little touch. They shot right back at any little bit of innuendo he batted their way. Even that little monster Bella was seen getting very close, and a little “handsy” here and there. That’s the part that got Carly excited. She could see it was working. Zane was just excited by all of it.

The fact that a lot of these girls had long term boyfriends made it even more fun. The girls would be as close and attentive as they could until certain people walked into the room. Then seats would shift, hands would pull away, and attention would turn to the other girls at the table. It was fascinating to watch.

In the meantime Zane was ready to test his power. Any time he could he started stealing kisses, grabbing asses, and groping titties, and the girls just went right along with it. In fact they seemed to be enjoying it. Some of them groping and grabbing right back.

It really did seem that Zane could take his pick at this point. He could offer any of them a ride home after school and see how far they were willing to go. In fact, that was the first thing he planned to do, just to see if they would bite. He changed his mind five times a day about who he should target first.

Of course his ultimate target was Bella. He kept trying to figure out how he was going to get Bella alone, and away from her boyfriend. Carly told him not to worry, if Bella wanted his vote, she would figure that out for him, and if she didn’t, Carly would arrange it herself.

The surprise was that Chloe was the most aggressive of them all. She would run up to him in the halls. She would sit with him at lunch. She didn’t need the vote, and she seemed to know it, but there she was hanging all over him any chance she got. Did she think the vote applied to the JV squad as well? He didn’t understand her motivation, but he didn’t really care either. After all, Chloe was one damned sexy girl.

Chloe again

Finally one day after school Zane got his answer. As he was sitting in his car getting ready to leave, he was watching a small group of the junior cheerleaders gathered near the school entrance, trying to decide who he would offer a ride to today. There was Stephanie, a very cute, spunky girl with bright blue eyes, a fantastic body, and that typical cheerleader spirit. She could be fun. There was also Natalie. Natalie was a tiny little Asian girl, maybe five feet tall at best, but she was so sexy. Natalie was small and skinny but still with perfect curves everywhere it mattered, and she had been all over Zane all week. He thought this just might be her lucky day. Time to just drive up and see if any of them wanted a ride.

As he pulled up to the sidewalk, almost where those girls were gathered, Chloe came running up and jumped in the passenger seat before he could even make his offer. Zane smiled and laughed as she climbed over to him, pulled him close, and gave him another big juicy kiss. He was just starting to enjoy it when she pulled back, settled in to the seat and said

“Can you give me a ride?”

Zane looked her up and down for a moment and thought to himself “Oh I can give you a ride!”

What he actually said was “To where?”

“Home” she answered.

He said “Well I wasn’t going home, but…”

Chloe interrupted “not your home, MY home”

Zane thought about it for a moment, again looking her over. She was wearing a light little pink top, very flimsy and unbuttoned half way down, leaving the sexy little red bra she was wearing exposed when she bent over him like that. She also wore a skirt that was dangerously short for school, which was already riding up her thighs farther than she probably wanted. He didn’t remember her wearing that in school all day, she must have changed after practice. He thought to himself, there’s no way you pass up an opportunity like this. Then he said “Okay… where do you live…”

This didn’t go unnoticed by the rest of the girls. The group he had been watching had also been watching him, and right now they all had their eyes on what was going on in Zane’s car, and they all followed as he drove out of the lot with Chloe. In his rear view mirror he could see them all watching.

Chloe has a plan

The drive to Chloe’s house was fairly short. He never knew where her family lived and it turned out to be not so far from his own house. As they drove Zane tried to subtly pry out of her why she was acting like such a little slut. Maybe not in quite those words, but she knew what he meant. Chloe let on that she knew he was the secret vote. He pointed out that it didn’t matter, there was no way she could become captain of the squad anyway. In return, Chloe pointed out that there was still a vote for JV Captain, and it couldn’t hurt to suck up to the secret vote now could it? Besides that, she really really liked kissing him.

What Zane didn’t know at the time was that Chloe had plans for him that day. He was going to take her virginity.

When Haley told her about Zane being the secret vote, she also let slip a few other details as to why. She said that he knew all the seniors. He knew all the juniors and sophomores as well. Plus everyone already knew that he had slept with Julie. That was a pretty well accepted rumor amongst them all since they had grown up next door to each other. There were rumors that he had slept with Sara too, although no one knew for sure about that one. Then she told the story of how she had watched him fucking her sister one day after school. She had thought it was Carly’s boyfriend at first but was shocked to find Zane instead. It was the only time she’d know her sister to cheat on her boyfriend. She couldn’t help but stand there and peep through the door the whole time. Even when he caught her watching, he just smiled and changed positions so she could see better and kept on going, like he wanted her to watch.

Chloe was getting wet just listening to her story.

Then Haley told her of how she had slept with him as well. At first Chloe called bullshit, but Haley went on to tell the whole story, in vivid detail. By the time she finished her story Chloe was so wet and horny that she was moaning and touching herself at the same time, imagining him doing all of that to her.

“Oh my god I can’t believe that.” She said. “That sounds so amazing, I wish I could do that, I wanna have sex so bad”

Haley answered “So go for it! You’re a cheerleader, I guarantee he’d fuck you if you let him”

Chloe said “Oh my god I would SOOOO let him, he’s so beautiful. But he’d never go for me, I’m just a freshman, he wants all the juniors and seniors”

Haley replied “Oh bullshit, I’m a freshman too and he didn’t have a problem doing it with me. All I had to do was be alone with him. Just invite him to your house when nobody’s home, then jump his ass”

They both giggled and screeched at that, and then went on to the more important details, how big is he, did it hurt, how could you fit all that inside you, what does it feel like, how long did you do it, how many times? Chloe closed her eyes and started dreaming of it already.

Plain and simple, Chloe was a raging ball of hormones. She wanted to fuck. She didn’t care about “being in love” or “saving myself” or “making the first time special”. She was just horny. All she really cared about was that itch between her legs, and now every time she saw Zane all she could think was “Oh my god I want to fuck you”

You want to WHAT?

When they arrived at Chloe’s house she insisted that he come inside, as if she could have stopped him. He expected her to offer him something to drink, or maybe a tour around the house. Instead, she locked the door, dropped her school things on the table, took Zane by the hand and led him straight up the stairs to her bedroom.

She pulled him into her room and pushed the door shut. Then she assumed her favorite position, her arms wrapped around his neck and her lips right on his. Zane was thinking damn! She might just make captain after all! They fumbled their way to her bed and collapsed on top of each other. Zane’s hands instinctively all over her body.

As Zane’s hands traveled from her tight little ass, over her sexy tummy, and eventually up to her tits, Chloe started moaning and giggling as she explored him as well. She was electrified by every little touch. She continued kissing and touching anywhere she could find skin. When Zane started to pull her shirt free, hoping to slide his hands up under it, Chloe sat up, looked at him, and asked,

“Did you really sleep with Haley?”

Not what he was expecting. He never did tell Haley not to tell anybody, but he didn’t think she would.

After a moment of fumbling over an answer he just said “What?”

Chloe said “Haley told me she had sex with you. Is it true?”

“When did she tell you that?” he asked.

Chloe answered “Last week, she was telling me about how you’re the secret vote because you’re so tight with all the seniors. Then she said that she saw you having sex with her sister, and then later SHE had sex with you too. Is that true? Did you really sleep with her?”

Zane considered for a quick moment in his head. She had been hanging all over him for the last week, apparently ever since Haley told her this. She had jumped in his car with her shirt practically off and her skirt half way up to her waist. Then she had lured him here to her bedroom with no one else home and the door shut. He figured, what the hell, why deny it?

So he answered, “Yeah well, after I caught her perving on me and Carly I figured the only way to keep her from blabbing was to do her too, so… yeah. But there wasn’t any sleeping going on.” Then he flashed her his biggest, naughtiest smile.

Chloe closed her eyes and threw herself back down on the bed and let out a heavy sigh. She said “Oh my god that sounds so amazing. I thought she was making it all up”

Zane answered “nope, it’s all true”

Chloe lay there for a moment, then rolled over to him, put her hand over his chest and her face right up close to his and said,

“I want to do it too”

“What?” he asked, knowing the answer of course.

Chloe came right out and said “I want what you did with Haley! I want you to fuck me”

Right Now?

Zane was only surprised that she came right out and said it. He looked at her and said “You do? Right now?”

Chloe answered eagerly “YES! Right now!”

Zane thought “Good, cuz that was gonna happen anyway”.

He considered for a moment and then asked “Are you on the pill?”

She answered “No”

Zane replied “Well if Haley told you the whole story, then she also told you that we thought she was pregnant for almost a month. I aint going through that again, and I don’t have any condoms with me. You want to go to my house?”

Chloe didn’t waste a moment, she reached over him to a drawer beside her bed and pulled out a string of about five condoms.

“I stole these from Sydney, she had them in her room. She’ll never know they’re missing!” she said as she proudly held them up.

Chloe’s older sister Sydney was away at college. She was an exact older version of Chloe, a little taller, a little more filled out, and a girl Zane would jump on in an instant. They literally could pass for twins.

He took the condoms from her hand and asked “You really want to do it?”

She practically climbed on top of him answering “I really do, Haley made me so horny telling me about it. It wanna do it, right now, so bad”

To test her resolve, Zane answered “Okay… take your clothes off”

Chloe didn’t even hesitate. She stood up, unbuttoned her shirt and off it came. Then the bra followed. She had been wearing the cutest little matching bra and panties, sexy little red silky things, they were on the floor in seconds. In just moments she was standing in front of him completely naked. What a sight. Her tits were bigger than he had thought and pointing straight at him now. Puffy dark little nipples standing straight out making them look even bigger. Her pussy was covered with neatly trimmed little patch of jet black hair. Clearly she had taken care to make it perfect. She had been thinking about this.

Zane dropped the condoms on the bed and stood up. He wanted to get his hands on that incredible little body in front of him but barely had a second before her hands started undoing his clothes.

Chloe is an ANIMAL

Chloe attacked Zane. She practically ripped his clothes off as fast as she could. At one point he asked about where the rest of her family was. She said her parents work late and her sister was at a friend’s house. They had at least two or three hours. Zane was confused about the sister, he thought she was at college. As it turns out there was another sister that Zane didn’t even know about, a younger sister who would be a freshman next year. Another sister? Riley? Next year might be fun too!

Chloe got to his shorts and pulled them down. Zane’s cock popped right out at her fully erect. She gasped at first sight of it. Chloe did have a couple of boyfriends this year, she had given hand jobs and even sucked a few cocks, but nothing like this. Zane seemed much bigger and harder than any of them. She immediately wrapped her mouth around the head. Zane completely forgot about her sisters and returned his attention to the head bobbing up and down on his cock.

Zane enjoyed her mouth for a few minutes, but he didn’t want to waste any time, he wanted to fuck her. As she knelt in front of him he grabbed one of the condoms and told her to put it on. She had no idea how to do it, so he helped her.

Zane knew she was a virgin. If she wasn’t there would never have been so much talk about “I want to have sex” and “It sounds so amazing” blab bla bla. They would have just made their way to her bed, gotten naked, and been fucking for twenty minutes already.

He laid on the bed and pulled her back up on top of him. She swung a leg up over his body and straddled his hips. Chloe looked amazing looming over him. He took in the moment, knowing he was about to be the first one to penetrate her. He was so hard by now he could barely stand it. He took his cock in hand and lined the head right up to her entrance. Slowly he rubbed the head back and forth against her lips. Chloe was entranced watching his cock about to enter her. After finding the right spot, Zane pushed the head inside her, watching her face as she experienced her first time.

Chloe let out a little gasp and a moan. Her eyes opened wide as Zane grabbed her hips and started to slowly pull her down onto his cock. Her mouth open in a perfect “O” as she slid down onto him. There was no resistance, no screams. He just slipped all the way up inside her on the first push. She stopped for a moment with him buried inside her and said “Oh my god!”

After a moment, Zane started a very slow rhythm back and forth, never really pulling out of her, but still creating that motion inside her, their hips rocking back and forth. He could feel her body grab and hold him tight with every thrust. Chloe slowly got used to it and began to moan, and to push back. Slowly the pace picked up a little. Now she was pulling herself up off of him and then thrusting back down. She would push back down on him hard and linger there. She seemed to like having his cock deep inside her. He did too.

While Zane did enjoy that, Chloe was just going too slow for him. He wanted to fuck this girl hard. He rolled her off of him and got her up on all four. Then he positioned himself behind her and entered her doggie style. He grabbed her hips and started to pound. Chloe started to moan and grunt with every thrust. Zane thought she might be hurting, being her first time and all, but soon those moans became a long string of Yes, yes, yes, yes.

Chloe was in heaven. This was everything she had hoped for and more. It hurt, at least at first, but now as Zane was pounding his cock into her from behind it was a hurt she couldn’t get enough. His cock felt so massive inside her. She had barely ever even put her fingers inside herself, and now this! Haley wasn’t even close when she described how this feels. There is no way to describe how this feels. Her arms collapsed and her head and shoulders fell to the bed. Still, Zane held on to her hips and just hammered his cock into her. It still hurt, but she couldn’t even imagine telling him to stop.

Finally Zane stopped and pulled out of her. Then he rolled her over on her back, grabbed one of her pillows and slid it under her ass. She started to relax from not having him inside her thinking it was over. “Oh my god that was so incredible” she thought. Then his fingers were suddenly on her pussy. This made her tingle all over again. When he touched her clit, it was like an electric jolt throughout her whole body. She screamed and opened her eyes wide. Zane was just smiling down at her.

For a few moments more he worked her clit until she was screaming at every little touch. Then he took her hand and brought it down to continue what he was doing. THAT she knew how to do. He knew she would. As she took over, he pulled her legs farther apart and drove his cock into her again. He took long hard strokes as deep as he could get, doing this as fast as he could. She looked so beautiful lying there, those perfect tits bouncing with his rhythm, her fingers working furiously, and his cock hammering into her again and again. She still hurt, but she had never felt anything like this in her life. She never wanted him to stop.

It seemed to last forever too, but then all too quickly she felt her body totally let go. She started to shake uncontrollably and she could feel her juices flowing from her. A long uncontrolled scream just escaped her involuntarily. Her legs clenched every time he drove into her. The feeling throughout her entire body was like nothing she had ever felt before, and still Zane kept driving into her again and again. Chloe was screaming at every thrust. Finally Zane let out a strenuous groan of his own and drove into her harder and deeper than he had yet. She could feel him cumming, even with the condom on. He held himself there for a moment, then pulled out and did it again. After a few more of these thrusts, he let her legs go and collapsed on top of her, both of them spent, sweaty and out of breath.

Zane rolled over next to her. Chloe cuddled up next to him and buried her head in his shoulder. She had been crying just a little bit.

She started talking, Zane just lay there lightly exploring her incredible body, not hearing a word she said. “That was the most amazing thing EVER. It hurt, but I couldn’t stop. I didn’t want to stop. Oh my god I want to do it again! But it was so much more than I ever expected. It’s like I can still feel it inside me…” She babbled on like that for a while about how much it hurt, how incredible it was, how she wanted to do it again, then finally she just sighed and cuddled close to him.

And the rumors fly!

Zane stayed for a while adoring the beautiful naked girl beside him, sucking on those tits. Fingering her some more. He barely had to touch her clit and she had another screaming orgasm. Her whole body was so sensitive right now. He so wanted to just use up all those condoms until her parents came home, but that would not have been good. Chloe wanted him to stay as well, but her whole family was due entirely too soon. Eventually he had to leave, leaving Chloe to clean up the mess they had made. Chloe would sleep well that night.

He hadn’t been home for more than an hour before he got a call from Carly…

“You fucked the freshman??!!”

Once he left, Chloe called Haley. Haley told Carly. Carly called Zane, that’s how fast the rumor mill works. He told Carly the whole story. Chloe was the first conquest as a result of their bet. As it turns out, not because he was the secret vote, but because Haley was telling all her friends she had sex, and they were all just as horny as she was.

Carly didn’t care, this would still work. As long as Chloe was a cheerleader it would still feed the rumor mill. By the end of the next day there was talk among the squad about Chloe fucking Zane. He knew for sure that no one had said anything to anyone else. Not him, or Chloe, or Carly, or Haley. The rumors had begun before Zane and Chloe had even left the parking lot. The fact that the rumor was true didn’t even matter. The talk amongst the juniors increased. Chloe would only be a sophomore next year, they would never pick a sophomore for captain…

Would they?

---